The problem is that there seems to be a general consensus that as long as you make an example out of a guy every once in a while, you can let other players behaviors slide.
And of coarse, the players you will let get away with it are the players that could help you win.
What sparked the BBSblog to bring up this issue?
Well... naturally the Roosters support of Todd Carney. I could understand it if it would have been the first, or even second offence. But this is... what? The fifth time in about as many years that the man has showed a complete disregard for rules and laws? Drinking and driving and reckless driving, reckless driving and driving without a license as well as failing to stop when directed by the police, urinating on a man, vandalism and now another drinking and driving.
So far we haven't heard about any sort of repercussions for Carney.
How many chances does a man repeatedly breaking laws get, compared to a man like Joel Monaghan who did do something dumb and revolting but didn't break any laws and was booted out on his ass?
We can ask Steve Irwin what he thinks of all the chances Todd Carney gets. Steve Irwin who was fired from the Raiders back in 2007 over having been in the car Todd Carney drove, and being the owner of the vehicle despite not having been charged with anything. Irwin hasn't played in the NRL since then. Meanwhile Todd Carney has been charged with various things... how many times now? Three times since 2007?
It's amazing how much being able to play the game of NRL well will let you get away with. But SHOULD it? Five times Todd Carney has broken the law, and he's still playing NRL grade. He's still not feeling any significant consequences for repeated violations of traffic laws. Meanwhile guys who haven't even broken any laws will get booted out, no second chances. Are players like Todd Carney, or Jonathan Thurston who retains his captaincy despite spending a night in jail last year, soaking up all the chances the NRL has above other players completely based on their on-field quality? Are we, as fans, also letting good players get away with bad behavior just because they can make our team win?
Does the NRL want to be a code with a clean conscience or a code with a lot of law breakers?
Who do we want to elevate? Players like Todd Carney, or players like Darren Lockyer, for example? Who would you rather have your child model their lives after, given the chance?
This isn't just about winning games or playing well. It's also about being a good role model, whether they want to be or not. Ina country like Australia, where drinking and driving is such a big problem, do you really want to send the message out to kids everywhere that it's not that big of a deal, as long as you're sorry afterwards?
I don't know. I don't think Todd should be completely banned from the NRL, but there were a few conditions he didn't want to agree to back in 2008. Put them in front of him now. Tell him that those are the conditions or he can leave, for good.
You can't keep giving a guy new chances when he's already had "another chance" four to five times now and not step up the consequences.
That's my opinion. I like Todd Carney as a player, but come on! The man can obviously not handle alcohol, and he obviously shouldn't be behind the wheel of a car. How hard is it to take a taxi if you know you're over the alcohol limit? Surely you must be able to afford that as an NRL superstar? How hard is it to get someone else to drive you? Surely you know enough people who'd be willing to do that to keep you from breaking the law? And if not, there is such a thing as buses and trains. If you can't afford that, you need someone to take care of your finances for you.
I'm not advocating being a hard-ass. I am advocating consistency and the clubs out there taking care of their players. Because the roosters are NOT doing Todd Carney any favors by standing behind him and watching him break the law, again.
Todd Carney and Jonathan Thurston are both brilliant players, but Todd Carney is a consistent law breaker. Jonathan Thurston might not quite be captain material yet.
I would love to see the NRL step up and make sure these players LEARN from their mistakes, that they are reprimanded and that consequences becomes a real thing. In the long run, I think we'll all benefit from it. Players, team, code, fans and country. All of us.